• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl: Authentic Chicago-Style Deep Dish & Wing Favorites in Cape Coral

East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl in Cape Coral brings authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizza with a sweet, rich sauce and perfectly balanced cheese. Known for its crispy-edge yet airy dough, this spot delivers a standout stuffed pizza experience that satisfies with just a slice. Customers praise the flavorful pan crust and perfectly cooked wings, highlighting the restaurant’s welcoming atmosphere and attentive service. The flexibility to customize crust styles, including a thin tavern option, adds appeal for diverse palates. Whether dining in or ordering delivery, East of Chicago Pizza captures the heart of Chicago’s classic flavors with fresh, hearty pies that keep locals coming back.

East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl at a glance

  • Address 4706 SE 9th Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33904, United States
  • Phone +1 239-360-7259
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Pizza takeaway .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner .

Photos & Gallery

East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl: Reviews & Ratings

Jenn Rae
5

I was craving a Chicago stuffed pizza and was pleasantly surprised to find East of Chicago pizza in Cape Coral. We have another Chicago pizza place downtown but they don't carry this pizza. It was a very easy experience ordering online for delivery. I was expecting it to arrive between 6:00 - 615pm but received a text around 5:50 pm that it had been delivered. At first I thought the crust was too soft but after eating a slice I didn't mind it. As we all know pizza sauce makes or breaks a pie. This sauce was a little sweet and delicious. It does only come in a medium size but I'm stuffed after one slice. This could easily feed a family of four, especially if you add salad and or wings. Overall this pie was exactly what I was craving. I don't normally eat pizza from chain restaurants but next time I'm craving a Chicago stuffed pizza I'll order from East of Chicago pizza.

Nancy B
5

Tried for the first time and grabbed a pan crust pizza and wings—both were excellent! The pizza was flavorful with great texture, and the wings were cooked perfectly with tons of taste. One thing to note: they offer Chicago-style pizza, which here means deep dish, not the Chicago tavern-style thin crust some people might expect. I asked about it, and they told me they can make a crispy crust that’s pretty comparable to the Chicago thin tavern style if that’s more your speed. Nice to have that flexibility! I will definitely be trying this next time!! Overall, awesome food, very friendly service, and I’ll definitely be going back!

Analade
5

The pizza was delicious! My husband brought some home with him and even heated up it was amazing! So I knew I had to get some fresh! The dough is crispy on the edges but nice and airy in the middle. The sauce is a perfect blend of sweet and tomatoey and the cheese actually pulls when you have it fresh!! We had the double pepperoni and it was covered!! The staff was also super welcoming and fun!! The inside was cool in temperature and had a low noise level when we went! Will be returning!!

Ronald Sweeris
5

In the area for work and figured is give them a shot. Wow! Place is very clean. The staff is very friendly and best of all the pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back when this area

Kathy Isenhour
5

Yummy sausage Chicago style pizza. Tasty crust, fresh sauce! Perfect amount of cheese! I will be back soon!

Erin H
5

Hidden gem for pizza and drinks. We like $1 beer night on Monday’s. 1/2 priced pizza Tuesdays . Pizza is good “like up north”.

Baran Inc
5

This pizza shop is the best in Cape Coral ! It’s like a real pizza joint. No gimmicks, no fake New Yorkers pretending to be from Long Island. Just good pizza. The crust is delicious and right amount of ingredients. I don’t know how this place is not packed every day. Perfect location, downtown Cape. Prices are very good. Fast friendly service. Huge variety, I love this place. Thank you.

Location

  • East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl
    East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl
    4706 SE 9th Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33904, United States Hotline: +1 239-360-7259

East of Chicago Pizza - SE 9th Pl, located in Cape Coral, FL, brings a solid taste of authentic Chicago-style deep dish right to your neighborhood. This pizza joint stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and classic recipes, delivering pies that satisfy both the craving for hearty, saucy slices and the need for a genuine Chicago pizza experience. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a highlight, perfectly balancing spicy buffalo sauce with creamy cheese and tender chicken, creating a bold flavor profile that lingers pleasantly after each bite.

Their 12-inch Chicago Style "Build Your Own" pizza offers a personalized experience, inviting pizza lovers to craft their ideal combination, from crust options to sauce and toppings. The deep dish here isn’t the thin, tavern-style crust some might expect but a thick, buttery crust that crisps on the edges while remaining airy inside—a textural harmony that complements the sweet, rich tomato sauce and generous cheese layers perfectly. Customers rave about the sauce, noting its sweet and tangy notes that elevate each slice, making the sauce the true star.

Ordering online is straightforward, with prompt delivery that gets your food to you hot and fresh. The staff’s friendly service enhances the experience, welcoming both first-timers and regulars to enjoy a relaxed dining atmosphere or a convenient takeout option. Whether you’re indulging in a stuffed sausage pie or sharing wings on the side, East of Chicago Pizza offers a satisfying, homey taste of Chicago’s pizza legacy without leaving Florida. This spot is a gem for anyone seeking authentic deep dish with consistent quality and flavorful depth.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards